What Safety-II/HOP Reveals About Investigations & (Not) Fixing Problems (Quickisode)

Why aren’t SIF / serious incident investigations fixing the issues that keep going wrong?

‘Never events’ are serious errors or incidents that are meant to be preventable. Hence, strong barriers should already be implemented.

Yet they keep happening, and disagreements remain about how much we learn by continually reinvestigating them.

In this Safe As quickisode, we unpack a study that reviewed 35 never event reports from a large NHS trust, rating how well each investigation evaluated the safety system and how strong its corrective actions were.

They found:
• Investigations are generally OK at listing contributing factors, but much weaker describing how work was normally done

• They identified 144 mismatches between what the work needed vs what the system provided, e.g. staff shortages, unworkable policies, IT limitations, and checklists missing critical items

• ~44% of mismatches had no action aimed at them

• Most actions targeted individuals, e.g. reminders, retraining, emails

• Interestingly, they argue that the often recommended SMART goals could inadvertently push investigators away from ambitious, upstream fixes

Finally, we explore practical takeaways using Safety-II / HOP ideas where treating an event as a window into the broader work system.

#SafetyII #HOP #HumanAndOrganisationalPerformance #IncidentInvestigation #PatientSafety #SIF #ResilienceEngineering

Anderson, J. E., & Watt, A. J. (2020). Using Safety-II and resilient healthcare principles to learn from Never Events. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 32(3), 196-203.

Leave a Reply