When talk isn’t cheap: Language and safety In two states’ human services

If an investigation isn’t about blame, then why do we still expect somebody to be blamed?

This study investigated how child welfare staff talked about incidents, blame & work – framed via first and second stories.

Background:

·     Investigations “still too often defaults to the accountability and responsibility of practitioners… which ‘naturally’ returns the locus of ‘remediation’ back to the individual(s)”

·     “rarely is any one employee empowered (enough) to be solely responsible for a critical decision”

·     “Accidents often occur when an untoward cascade of events takes place. However, this is generally discovered only after the fact and only when a single actor is held to be responsible”

·     First stories are “superficial, (initial) understanding of events”, “heavily impacted by hindsight, outcome and severity biases” & “characterized by variants on ‘human error’ (e.g. complacent, situationally unaware, lazy, etc.)”

·     Second stories provide “more context rich narrative” focusing on “the view from the inside” & “the systemic contributions that ultimately helped set people at the sharp end up for failure (e.g. incentives, policy changes, time pressures, workload, etc.)”

·     2nd stories “look beyond default explanations that rely on ‘human error'”

Results:

·     “Every single meeting I’ve ever sat in there’s a ceremonial spiel of ‘This is not to finger-point and this is not to place blame’ but it doesn’t matter”

·     But “someone is always looking for someone to blame”

·     “The notion of accountability upward is not part of who we are…[it’s] collateral accountability that goes down but not necessarily up”

·     One provider removed “med passing privileges after three med errors”, but after changing their approach: “the error was less the person’s and more from all the circumstances we needed to address”

·     Changing their approach led to staff seeing reviews as producing “a new and powerful kind of evidence that would be more difficult for others to ignore or dismiss”

·     They “did not believe that blame and finger-pointing would cease to be a guiding principle in their organizations”

·     E.g. until “safety science addresses the issue of hierarchy head on, safety solutions will ultimately default to the norm”

In all, “[T]alk, seemingly the most ephemeral and transient of social phenomenon, can be a vehicle for understanding and changing staff’s perception of the workplace and their jobs”

“[W]e must resist the temptation to believe…we know more about how to bring safety to the workplace than those who work there”

Ref: Nyce, J. M., Bader, G., Smoker, A., Hengelbrok, N., Modell, S., & Dekker, S. W. A. (2025). When talk isn’t cheap: Language and safety in two states’ human services. Journal of Risk Research, 28(5), 471–485.

Study link: https://doi.org/10.1080/13669877.2025.2512077

#SafetyCulture #HumanFactors #SafetyScience #JustCulture #IncidentInvestigation

Leave a Reply